April 21, 1890
Match: Earl of Wharncliffe Charity Cup, Final, replay, at Olive Grove, kick-off: 17:10.
Staveley – Rotherham Town 1-1 (1-0).
Referee: Mr. J. Fox; umpires: Messrs.: T.A. Tomlinson and J. Ward.
Staveley (2-3-5): Will Lilley, Harry Lilley, J. Cook, A. Booth, J. Rice, S. Hay, W. Marshall, Ernest Needham, J. Hay, S. Wilshaw, W. Needham.
Rotherham Town (2-3-5): Arthur Wharton, Halliden, Turner, W. Damms, A. Rodgers, Ted Cross, Bridgewater, Longden, Wortley, McKie, McCormick.
The goals: 1-0 Hay (11 min.), 1-1 Own goal (Cook).