September 17, 1891
Match: Tour of the American-Canadians, at Abbey Park.
Grimsby Town – Canadians 4-0 (3-0).
Grimsby Town (2-3-5):
Canadians (2-3-5): Alexander Noble Garrett, E.J. Gregory, Joseph V. Buckley, Dr John Clark Warbrick, James J. Dalton, Henry Waring, James Whittaker, Alex Jefffey, Dennis Shea, Ernie C. Senkler, Neil Munro.
The goals: 1-0 Ackroyd, 2-0 Ackroyd, 3-0 Ackroyd, 4-0 Riddoch.