September 11, 1893
Fred Geary, as is well-known, or should be by every true Evertonians, takes a well-earned benefit this evening, when Everton try conclusions once more with their oldest and most popular rivals, the Bolton Wanderers.
A match in which these teams are the principals is sure to be worth seeing, whether it be a cup tie, a League, or a friendly. It is of the latter class for this interesting event, but it should prove very attractive independently of the opportunity it affords of doing honour and showing appreciation of one of the heroes of the Everton camp.
It may be that Geary is not now so conspicuous an actor as he has been; but if that is so, it is owing to the fact that he has been so frequently placed hors de combat during the later part of his career. When fit and well he yet remains a thorn in the side of any defenders, however powerful and alert they may be. He has been nursing a sprained leg, received whilst practising three weeks ago, or would doubtless have been seen very much in evidence before now this season.
Geary did more individually to place Everton in the forefront three seasons ago than perhaps any other member of the team. His electric runs as centre forward were unique in their effectiveness. His speed carried him to the face of goal before his opponents could realise the situation, and as he could shoot hard and direct he instantly became a great favourite with the spectators and a terror to his foremen.
In a certain price competition, organised by a contemporary in 1889, he gained far and away the greatest number of votes as the best footballer, up to date. He may not have been the cleverest all-round man, notwithstanding the favourable vote he received, but he had made a great impression, and it proved his popularity.
Since then he has gained international honours – in particular playing for England against Scotland in 1891 – and even last year he scored more goals, we understand, for Everton, though not playing regularly as others, than anyone else. Having proved himself so dangerous, Geary soon realised that he was a “marked” man, with the result that he has been knocked about more than most centre forward, the greater so from his lithe build. His effectiveness has suffered in consequence to some extent. Still he has done well by his club, and deserves to be tangibly rewarded, especially for the part he played in helping Everton to secure the League championship in 1890-1.
(Source: Liverpool Mercury: September 11, 1893)
"Play Up, Liverpool" 